Menu

At Nancy’s, you’ll always find a variety of traditional and seasonal ice cream flavors to choose from, as well as sorbets and other specialty frozen desserts. All homemade, all created using locally-sourced ingredients.

Super-Premium Hard Ice Cream

Chocolate: the chocolate you dream of; Fruition's 68% dark milk, cocoa from Peru
Vanilla: Tahitian beans bring floral notes and big flavor
Coffee: our breakfast favorite, using Catskill Roasters “Mood Indigo” blend
Banana:  caramelized in dark rum with brown sugar
Sour Cream Cherry: a Woodstock exclusive featuring Italian, Amarena cherries
Chocolate Marshmallow: our chocolate with marshmallow swirl
Vanilla with Chocolate Cookie Crumble: our vanilla with cookie crunchies
Stout: made with local, craft beer - varieties change with season
Cream Cheese Carrot Cake
: cream cheese and carrot ice creams with carrot cake pieces
Honey: local honey in our custard base
Peanut Butter
: spun with creamy peanut butter
Butter Pecan: traditional favorite

 

Vegan & Dairy Free

Vanilla Bean Coconut:  Tahitian beans in coconut cream, a vegan "ice cream"
Mint Chocolate Chip: mint and chocolate in coconut cream, a vegan "ice cream"
Chocolate: creamy chocolate with a hint of coconut, a vegan "ice cream"

Served in a Cup
Single Scoop $3.75
Double Scoop $6.50
Triple Scoop $7.50
Dairy Ice Cream Buy the Pint $9.00
Dairy Ice Cream Buy the Quart $18.00
Vegan Buy the Pint $10.00
Vegan Buy the Quart $20.00

 

Extras
Waffle Cone $0.50
Nut or Streusel Topping $0.25
Hot Fudge, Caramel Sauce $0.25
Wet Walnuts (Catskills Maple Syrup) $0.25
Vanilla or Chocolate Whipped Cream $0.50
Rainbow or Chocolate Sprinkles Free!

Outrageous Sundaes

Sundae (2 scoops) $7.75 | Banana Split (3 scoops) $9.75 | Mini Sundae (1 scoop) $5.50

Brownie Sundae
vanilla ice cream, brownie pieces, hot fudge, chocolate whipped cream, peanuts

Banana Chocolate Sundae
banana and chocolate ice creams, hot fudge, banana bread and brownie pieces, chocolate whipped cream, oatmeal streusel

Irish Sundae
stout ice cream, whiskey caramel, baileys whipped cream, chocolate-dipped pretzel pieces

Nancy's Sandwich Cookie Sundae
vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, Nancy's chocolate + cream sandwich cookies

Grasshopper Sundae
vegan mint chocolate chip ice cream, hot fudge, chocolate cookie crumble, whipped cream

S'Mores Sundae
chocolate ice cream, hot fudge, graham cracker crumbs, marshmallow sauce, whipped cream

Chocolate - Chocolate Sundae
chocolate ice cream, chocolate cake pieces, marshmallow sauce, chocolate whipped cream, candied walnuts

Carrot Cake Sundae
swirled cream cheese and carrot ice creams, carrot cake pieces, caramel sauce, whipped cream, oatmeal streusel

Caramelized Banana Sundae
banana and cream cheese ice creams, banana bread pieces, caramel sauce, whipped cream, oatmeal streusel

Sour Cream Cherry Sundae 
sour cream cherry ice cream, white cake pieces, cherry syrup, whipped cream, candied walnuts

Vegan Vanilla Sundae
vegan vanilla coconut cream ice cream, carrot cake pieces, vegan coconut whipped cream, pecans

Vegan Chocolate Sundae
vegan chocolate coconut ice cream, vegan coconut whipped cream, pecans

Nancy's Banana Split
vanilla, chocolate and banana ice creams, caramel sauce, hot fudge, banana bread, whipped cream, oatmeal streusel

Ice Cream Sandwiches

Our Ice Cream Layered Between Our Cookies $4.00 each
Grab One and Go!

PB Krispie: peanut butter + krispy rice cookies, vanilla + chocolate ice cream swirl - Classic!
Chocolate: chocolate cookie, chocolate ice cream - Divine!
Vanilla: chocolate cookie, vanilla ice cream - Awesome!
Chocolate Chip: chocolate chip cookie, vanilla ice cream - Made Before Your Eyes!

 

Milkshakes

Cool, Rich Deliciousness, $8.75 each

Chocolate Malt: vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, malt
Mocha Hazelnut: chocolate + coffee ice cream, nutella sauce, malt, chocolate whipped cream
Bourbon: vanilla ice cream, bourbon, vanilla extract, honey, cinnamon, whipped cream, caramel sauce
Caramel + Pretzel: vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce, whipped cream, crushed pretzels
Banana Cream Pie: banana + cream cheese ice cream, milk, whipped cream, graham cracker crumbs
Almond Joy
: vegan chocolate coconut, dairy vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, toasted almonds
Snicker Bar: vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce, hot fudge, milk, peanut butter, whipped cream, peanuts

 

Drinks

Something Different

Coffee - $2.50
robust and smooth

Affogato - $5.50
espresso over 2 mini-scoops vanilla ice cream

Ice Cream Cakes

Made-to-Order Please call 2 days  ahead 845-684-5329
With Message of Your Choice - Free

8" Round (serves 12) - $40.00
1/4 Sheet (serves 24) - $80.00
1/2 Sheet (serves 48) - $120.00
Buy-the-Slice - $7.75

Varieties
Sprinkles: 3 layers white cake, 2 layers chocolate ice cream, whipped cream, sprinkles
Sour Cream Cherry: 3 layers white cake, 2 layers sour cream cherry ice cream, whipped cream, roasted pecans
Carrot: 3 layers carrot cake, 2 layers cream cheese ice cream, whipped cream, roasted pecans
Chocolate: 3 layers chocolate cake, 2 layers vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, oatmeal streusel
Chocolate Marshmallow: chocolate ice cream, marshmallow sauce swirl, chocolate cookie crumble, candied walnuts
Nancy's Cookie Crumble: chocolate ice cream, chocolate cookie crust, cookie crumble, vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce, hot fudge, whipped cream
Banana Terrine: banana + cream cheese ice creams, graham crumbs, caramel sauce, candied walnuts
PB + Chocolate Torte: c
hocolate + peanut butter ice cream, chocolate cookie crust, hot fudge
Tiramisu: espresso-soaked sponge cake, coffee + cream cheese ice creams, whipped cream

 

Pies

Made-to-Order Please call 2 days  ahead 845-684-5329
8" round, $40.00 each

Key Lime Pie: tart + sweet filling on graham cracker crust, with 1 quart Sour Cream Cherry Ice Cream
Mud Pie: chocolate cookie crust, flourless brownie, chocolate ice cream, chocolate crumble

 

Baked Delights

Variety of quick bites on the counter each day, $2.00 each
Visit or Call for today's selections