At Nancy’s we make real, fresh ice cream – everything from the familiar flavors of your childhood to modern, whimsical, even exotic new tastes. We live in the Catskills, so we’re passionate about using only local ingredients that we source from local dairy and produce farms.

[ More About Us ]
You can taste the Catskills in every lick, sip, and brain-freezy bite.
Locally-sourced ingredients:

This is small batch, artisanal ice cream made on premise. Some varieties even have a custard base that’s stirred on our stove top. Our menu changes with the availability of naturally-ripened local fruits and other ingredients – so stop in often to taste our seasonal flavors.


[ Flavors of the Month ]


Always on the menu:

Gourmet, hand-scooped waffle cones, sundaes with inventive toppings, thick milkshakes, ice cream sandwiches, vegan and non-dairy treats like sorbet. We also serve pies, cookies and cakes – all baked in our shop.


[ Our Traditional Flavors ]


Here’s more about Nancy’s story!

Facebook Feed

Now open till 9:00pm, Fridays and Saturdays! ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Looking for a unique birthday surprise? Try our white cake with sour cream cherry ice cream whipped cream and roasted pecans. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Did you know that our ice cream flavors can be ordered by the pint? Give us a call at (845) 684-5329. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

At Nancy's, we get all our ingredients fresh, and utilize as many local producers as possible. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

We have a winner! The inaugural flavor shall be (drum roll…) STRAWBERRY BALSAMIC! Thank you for voting in our contest. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook